天水讼
By Yarrow Editorial · Updated , published
Hexagram 6 addresses situations of dispute, contention, and the pull toward prolonged conflict. Its counsel is generally cautious: even when you have a strong case, pressing it to the limit often costs more than it gains.
Song (讼) is the sixth hexagram of the received sequence: heaven moving upward, water flowing downward, 天水讼 — two real forces traveling away from each other. The judgment is one of the most carefully balanced in the book. You are sincere yet obstructed; a cautious halt halfway brings good fortune; going through to the end brings misfortune. It furthers one to see the great man; it does not further one to cross the great water.
讼:有孚窒惕,中吉,终凶。利见大人,不利涉大川。
Interpretive translationConflict. You are sincere yet are being obstructed. A cautious halt halfway brings good fortune; going through to the end brings misfortune. It furthers one to see the great man; it does not further one to cross the great water.
彖曰:讼,上刚下险,险而健,讼。讼有孚窒惕中吉,刚来而得中也。终凶,讼不可成也。利见大人,尚中正也。不利涉大川,入于渊也。
象曰:天与水违行,讼;君子以作事谋始。
不永所事,小有言,终吉。
象曰:不永所事,讼不可长也。虽小有言,其辩明也。
If one does not perpetuate the affair, there is a little gossip, but the end brings good fortune.
不克讼,归而逋,其邑人三百户,无眚。
象曰:不克讼,归逋窜也。自下讼上,患至掇也。
One cannot engage in conflict; returning home, one lies low. The people of the town, three hundred households, remain free of harm.
食旧德,贞厉,终吉。或从王事,无成。
象曰:食旧德,从上吉也。
To nourish oneself on ancient virtue brings perseverance. Danger, yet good fortune in the end. Serving the king, seek no works of one's own.
不克讼,复即命,渝安贞,吉。
象曰:复即命,渝安贞,不失也。
One cannot engage in conflict. One turns back and submits to fate, changes one's attitude, and finds peace in perseverance. Good fortune.
讼,元吉。
象曰:讼元吉,以中正也。
To contend before him brings supreme good fortune.
或锡之鞶带,终朝三褫之。
象曰:以讼受服,亦不足敬也。
Even if by chance a leather belt is bestowed, by morning's end it has been snatched away three times.
Orientation: what Hexagram 6 is pointing at
For beginners, the safest way to read this hexagram is as a cost question, not a justice question. It does not say conflict is always wrong — sometimes a dispute must be addressed directly, and the fifth line shows a case brought before a fair authority ending in supreme good fortune. What it consistently warns against is taking conflict all the way to its conclusion, when winning and losing have become the same thing.
The structure explains why escalation is the default danger. Below is Kan, water, cunning and depth; above is Qian, heaven, force and conviction. Two strong parties, each certain, each moving away from the other. The hexagram does not doubt your sincerity — the judgment grants it. It doubts the economics of pursuing sincerity through combat.
The Image commentary draws the practical lesson: heaven and water move in opposite directions — Conflict; therefore the noble one, in all transactions, carefully considers the beginning. Most disputes are lost or won at the moment of their design — in the contract, the expectation, the unspoken assumption — long before the first argument. Song read early is prevention; read late, it is damage control.
Knowing when to stop: reading the six lines
The six lines of Song form a ladder of disengagement. The first line gives the best outcome: do not perpetuate the affair — there is a little gossip, but the end brings good fortune. Letting a small dispute die early costs you some talk and saves you everything else.
The second and fourth lines share one verb: cannot. One cannot engage in conflict — returning home, one lies low, and the household stays unharmed. One cannot engage in conflict — one turns back, submits to what is right, changes one's attitude, and finds peace. Both lines treat retreat not as defeat but as accurate arithmetic: some opponents and some arenas are structurally unwinnable, and recognizing that is strength.
The third line counsels living on ancient virtue — hold to what is proven, serve without claiming credit, and the danger passes. The fifth line is the exception that defines the rule: a dispute brought before a truly central and correct arbiter ends in supreme good fortune. And the top line is the hexagram's grim little parable — even if you win the leather belt of office, it is snatched away three times before the morning ends. Victory won through conflict carries its reversal inside it.
Reading Hexagram 6 in love and relationships
In relationship questions, Hexagram 6 marks a bond that has turned adversarial: scorekeeping, litigating old grievances, conversations that feel like depositions. Its first instruction is the first line's — do not perpetuate the affair. Most relationship conflicts are survivable if they are not promoted into permanent institutions. The couple that can let a dispute stay small outperforms the couple that wins every argument.
When the dispute is real and cannot be dropped, the hexagram's second instruction applies: see the great man. In a relationship that means a fair third party — a counselor, a trusted elder, a shared framework — rather than escalating to friends-as-juries. And the Image's advice about beginnings is the deepest relationship counsel in the hexagram: the fights that cannot be resolved are usually about expectations that were never agreed. Renegotiate the beginning, and the end often dissolves on its own.
Reading Hexagram 6 for career and decisions
For career and business questions, Hexagram 6 is the litigation hexagram in the broad sense: contract disputes, partnership friction, credit battles, political contests inside organizations. Its default advice is settle early and cheaply. The second and fourth lines both say the party that recognizes an unwinnable posture and withdraws preserves its people and its position — pride is the only casualty.
The exception matters. The fifth line says that if a dispute must be decided, bring it before genuine authority — a real arbiter, a clean process, a decision-maker both sides accept — and that path can end supremely well. What the hexagram forbids is the third road: private war without arbiter, fought to exhaustion, won at the cost of the victory's value.
For a yes-or-no decision — should I press this claim, file this suit, force this issue — Hexagram 6 leans toward no unless three conditions hold: the matter cannot be settled, a legitimate arbiter exists, and what you would win survives the winning. If any condition fails, the hexagram's arithmetic says the belt you win will be taken back three times before the day is out.
When Hexagram 6 is a warning
Hexagram 6 is most dangerous when it is read as vindication. It grants your sincerity; it does not grant your strategy. The person who hears you are right and stops listening is precisely who the top line is written for — right, victorious, and stripped of the prize by evening. Being wronged is a fact about the past; the hexagram is about the future, and in the future the dispute itself is the main threat.
A practical way to hold the reading: Song confirms that obstruction is real and that you are not imagining the grievance. Then run its three moves in order. Can this be dropped small — the first line? Can it be settled through withdrawal or arbitration — the second, fourth, and fifth lines? And if neither, does the prize survive the fight — the top line's test? Most situations that receive this hexagram resolve at move one or two. The ones that do not were never really about the dispute.
Frequently asked questions
What does Hexagram 6 mean in an I Ching reading?
Hexagram 6, Song or Conflict, shows heaven rising and water sinking — two forces moving apart. It means a dispute or adversarial dynamic is the central fact of the situation, and it judges the economics of fighting: you may be sincere and in the right, but a cautious halt halfway brings good fortune while going through to the end brings misfortune. It favors seeing a fair arbiter — the great man — and warns against grand undertakings while conflict is live. Read it as a cost question about contention, not a verdict on who is right.
Is Hexagram 6 good or bad luck?
It is cautionary rather than unlucky. Several lines end in good fortune — dropping the affair early, withdrawing from an unwinnable posture, returning to what is proven — and the fifth line says a dispute brought before a truly fair arbiter ends supremely well. What the hexagram calls misfortune is specific: fighting to the end. The top line's image is a winner whose prize belt is snatched away three times before morning ends. So the luck depends on behavior — settle or arbitrate and it reads well; escalate and even victory spoils.
What does Hexagram 6 mean for love and relationships?
In love, Hexagram 6 marks a relationship that has turned adversarial — scorekeeping, relitigating old grievances, arguments run like trials. Its first counsel is the first line's: do not perpetuate the affair; let small disputes stay small, and the end is good. Where a dispute is real, it advises a fair third party rather than escalation, and its deepest advice comes from the Image — conflicts that cannot be resolved usually trace to beginnings never properly agreed, so renegotiate the expectations rather than winning the argument.
What does Hexagram 6 mean for a career decision?
For career questions, Hexagram 6 governs disputes in the broad sense — contract friction, partnership splits, credit battles, office politics. Its default is settle early and cheaply; the second and fourth lines show withdrawal from an unwinnable posture preserving everything but pride. The exception is the fifth line: if the matter must be decided, bring it to a legitimate arbiter both sides accept. For a press-or-drop decision it leans toward drop unless the dispute cannot be settled, a real arbiter exists, and the prize would survive the winning.
Related reading
Move from research into a real reading
If this page helped you frame the question, the next step is to run a reading with that same clarity.